135
Monday, April 23, 2018 - 04:26 PM UTC
Roden shares images of its kit sprues.
The Holt 75 was a heavy artillery tractor, produced in the early 20th Century by inventor Benjamin Holt in the United States. At first it was used exclusively for agricultural needs, but with the outbreak of the First World War it was brought into military service as a mover of heavy artillery pieces that could not be hauled by the physically limited horse-drawn harness. In addition to Great Britain, these machines were also used by France and the United States. A total of 2,000 tractors of this type took part in the First World War. They became the forerunner of a major new element in the mechanized army - the artillery tractor, since used with great success up to the current day.

Roden's Holt 75 Artillery tractor (812) is offered as an injection-molded kit. It includes decals to depict a model of a vehicle used by the US Expeditionary Forces in Europe.
Click Star to Rate
7 readers have rated this story.
Get a daily email with links to all our latest news, reviews, and features.

Comments

You can easily see that long sink line along the centre line of the corrugated roof. It is meant to be a single curved piece...... You would have thought that they would at least have tried to find an example without the sink marks for the press shots, so it seems they’re not really concerned about the rubbish they’re churning out. .
MAY 31, 2018 - 09:54 PM
I don't think it is a sink line. It looks too regular. Looks like they have made a mistake. Should be possible to fix. / Robin
MAY 31, 2018 - 10:41 PM
Yes, I see what you are talking about. I can't tell from the sprue shots, but I suspect this is because Roden chose to cast a central roof support. I've seen a real Holt (re-conditioned) with a roof support like that, and an old rusty one with the roof split into halves lengthwise as well (a logging camp model). But I believe (from my model railroading experience with Holt 75s) that the original roof was a one piece affair with either a central support or two parellel supports. The roof should be one piece, or at least have overlapped peices, so there shouldn't be any seam down the middle like that, unless it has been modified. Given the limits of polystyrene casting, I'd think I'd want to replace the roof anyway with either thin sheet brass or aluminum, although Evergreen makes some corrugated styrene material that would work too (but be a little thick perhaps?). Corrugated polystyrene is just harder to get right in any case. Somebody (Small Shop?) makes a form for producing scale thickness corrugations in metal, but I forget who it is now. There used to be at least one model railroad manufacturer that makes corrugated aluminum sheet in HO, O, and G scale which might also be used (Detail Associates perhaps?). You might try the Walthers Catalog. VR, Russ
JUN 01, 2018 - 03:22 AM
Those long pieces to the left of the roof have me wondering as to what they could be. They don't have the same shape as the fenders in this image/box-art For a short time I was thinking that the sprue image showed the underside of the roof and the channel was there to receive the central roof beam but then the hole for the exhaust seems to be on the wrong side. The thickness of the plastic roof can be hidden with the rolled up curtains. Fixing the ditch in the corrugated roof is doable but it will be a lot of work. It is still better than scratch building the whole thing .... / Robin
JUN 01, 2018 - 04:23 AM
Those ARE the mudguards. You are expected to fold/bend down the two ends to give the shape shown in the boxart. This kit will still need a measure of scratchbuilding to make anything decent out of it. First step is to see how small the Archer resin rivets are made. Many are lost as you put the pieces together and try to loose the join seams. The turntable for the front wheel seems to be the biggest scratchbuilding challenge sk
JUN 01, 2018 - 05:07 AM
I have been making models for over 50 years. After a few more hours work on the Holt, I have revised my opinion. It is absolute tripe and fit fit only for the bin. Nothing fits, everything is covered in flash and the instructions so poor that you can’t tell where pieces should be positioned. Steer clear of the thing, Run away from it, and don’t look back. An expensive lesson in avoiding anything and everything that has the Roden name on it in the future.
JUN 01, 2018 - 11:53 PM
Good advice, but-- I only have one question-- is this your first Roden Kit? I've found their AFVs are usually more challenging than thier aircraft (early issues that is-- their first aircraft kits were real "bears"). VR, Russ
JUN 02, 2018 - 03:47 AM
Another setting for the Holt tractor is this one: bringing up ammunition to the English/Australian Army to fight against the combined forces of the Ottoman/Turk/German alliance during the Battle of Be'ersheba, October 1917, on the territory now known as Israel.
AUG 28, 2018 - 04:02 AM
Sooo-- after a long period of looking at this kit, I finally broke down and bought one. It has several issues as mentioned in comments in this review, BUT-- I was able to build and paint mine --mostly out of the box--, in about three weeks working 2-4 hours a day 5 days a week (along with the Roden 8" BL Howitzer). I found correcting the sink marks in the roof was pretty easy. The front wheel was fiddly for sure, and needed a lot of clean up with a scalpel and sanding sticks, the water and fuel tank seams and rivets need some work, but nothing that can't be carefully accomplished. The fit was questionable in a few areas, but nothing that couldn't be overcome. Close attention to the instructions is necessary, and a few good photos of the real thing will certainly help your build. You may want to deviate from the instructions in a few areas and build in sub-assemblies. I was actually impressed with the detail and engineering in several areas of the kit. Sure, it has several "warts" in fit and some parts need to be re-worked with a sharp blade, but I can now say from experience that a modeler with moderate skills can create a nice model from the kit. Just keep your scalpel, sandpaper, sanding sticks, a little putty and some "elbow grease" at hand. Bottom line-- don't fear this kit, if a Holt 75 is something you've been waiting for, and you have the tools and skills at hand-- buy this kit. Rick Taylor and I are working on a joint build article for this kit and the Roden 8" BL Howitzer (which I also just finished) those of you who are interested in WWI Artillery will be glad to know that Roden has filled an open Niche for American (and British) Heavy Artillery quite nicely with these two kits, at a reasonable price. VR, Russ.
APR 18, 2019 - 02:56 AM
THIS STORY HAS BEEN READ 7,224 TIMES.
ADVERTISEMENT

Photos
Click image to enlarge
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
Roden ReviewsMORE
BL 8-Inch Howitzer Built Review
by Rick Taylor | of 1 ratings, 100% found this helpful
Holt 75 Tractor Built Review
by Russ Bucy | of 1 ratings, 100% found this helpful
BL 8-Inch Howitzer In-Box Review
by Rick Taylor
M43 3/4 Ton Ambulance Built Review
by Kevin Brant | of 1 ratings, 100% found this helpful
Holt 75 Artillery Tractor In-Box Review
by Kevin Brant
FLAK 88 VOMAG In-Box Review
by Is a secret | of 1 ratings, 100% found this helpful
Roden KrAZ 255B In-Box Review
by Russ Amott
Ludewig Built Review
by Russ Amott
Soviet Medium Truck KrAZ-214B In-Box Review
by Gino P. Quintiliani | of 3 ratings, 100% found this helpful
Opel Blitz omnibus W39 late Built Review
by Russ Amott | of 3 ratings, 67% found this helpful
sd.kfz 4/1 (8cm) Built Review
by Russ Amott | of 2 ratings, 100% found this helpful
Roden Vielfachwerfer Built Review
by Matthew Lenton | of 5 ratings, 100% found this helpful
Opel 3.6-47 Stabswagen Built Review
by Russ Amott | of 8 ratings, 88% found this helpful
Munitionskraftwagen Sd.Kfz.4 Built Review
by Russ Amott | of 4 ratings, 100% found this helpful
Opel 3.6-47 Omnibus Built Review
by Russ Amott | of 4 ratings, 100% found this helpful

ADVERTISEMENT