login   |    register

Scale Modeling Sponsors

See Your Ad Here!

Model Centrum Publishing [ MORE REVIEWS ] [ WEB SITE ] [ NEW STORIES ]

Book Review
M4a2 Sherman (Part 1) APG #11

by: Jim Rae [ JIMBRAE ]

Introduction: In praise of Polish Publishers...

On a recent vacation in Poland, I was fortunate enough to pick up a number of publications covering a variety of vehicles and subjects.
This particular series of books - Armor PhotoGallery, currently has 12 titles in the series covering a variety of vehicles all in broadly the same format. Fortunately the publishers in Poland, the Czech Republic and Russia are now beginning to get the coverage they deserve. These countries have a considerable number of publishing houses who are producing the kind of material which the modeller has been crying out for for years - at a price which makes them accessible for all modellers.
The book...

M4A2 Sherman Part 1 (Armor PhotoGallery #11), written by Wojciech J. Gawrych is an A4, soft-cover book consisting of 80 pages, 201 color photos, 74 black and white photos and 7 pages of scale drawings. Despite it's 'Polish' Pedigree, the book is written in English throughout. The subject of the book is the early/middle production 75mm M4a2 with the 56° hull. Future volumes will doubtless cover the 76mm M4a2.

The book is divided into three distinct sections:

Part 1 - Consists of very detailed photos of a series of preserved vehicles throughout the world - Sweden, France and Canada. Each photo helpfully comes with a tiny flag to indicate its source as there are some slight detail variations. Interspersed are details from the original technical manuals which serve to accentuate a particular detail or variation. The (always) complex subject of suspension variations are covered in some depth - again comparison is a keynote. Another noteworthy addition is a small (highlighted) graphic at the top of each page which shows what area is being covered - mantlet, tracks etc... The fighting comparent comes in for special attention as does the engine compartment and power plant - vital for those who want to go the 'whole-hog' and model the engine convincingly.

Part 2 Is the Scale Drawing section. As I mentioned previously, plans are provided in both 1/72nd and 1/35th scale. The former is particularly useful as making a copy of the former and increasing it by a factor of 50% gives one a set of 1/48th scale plans. Four vehicles are covered in the plans:

British Sherman III Command vehicle (early production)

M4a2 Early Production

Sherman III (Intermediate production)

M4a2 (later production)


The final section, Part 3 consists of 22 pages of 'contemporary' photos showing the M4a2 (or Sherman III) in service, under construction and on the proving grounds. The 'in-service' photos cover a considerable number of vehicles with the emphasis very strongly on Polish vehicles although there are a number of interesting photos of New Zealand vehicles as well. Each of the photographs has a well-considered commentary, pointing out detail variations and explaining the situation where the photo was taken.
Conclusions.

The drawback of this book lies not in the superb work done by Wojciech J. Gawrych, but rather in the limitations imposed by the kit manufacturers. To date, no manufacturer has seen fit to produce a plastic kit of the '56° hull' M4a2 in 1/35th scale and to produce one, it inevitably necessitates turning to one of the AM Manufacturers for the correct hull... We can but hope that this book is now in the hands of the design section of DML, Trumpeter or Italeri.
These 'drawbacks' aside, this is a superbly executed book and bodes well for future titles in the series. The quality of the images is sharp and clear, the use of the original manuals is a useful touch also. The section of contemporary photos is absolutely invaluable (particularly for those like myself who have become recent 'converts' to Polish Armor!). At first the layout does seem a touch chaotic until the logic of the compilation is understood. The use of three different vehicles is an interesing idea as sadly, too many authors use 'single-source' - anyone who has gone 'into' the Sherman in any detail will rapidly come to the conclusion that variation within vehicles of the same designation was the rule rather than the exception. I confidently predict that this 'series' within a series will find its way onto many modellers shelves in the coming months and years and whilst few titles will substitute Hunnicutt as a primary source, the publishers of this series deserve real success with this, and future books....

VERY HIGHLY RECOMMENDED

Further details


M4A2 Sherman Part 1 (Armor PhotoGallery #11) By Wojciech J. Gawrych is published by Model Centrum Progres, Warsaw, Poland Their website, listing this and the other books in the series, can be seen HERE

My copy was purchased directly from JadarModel in Warsaw who have this and many other superb publications available for world-wide mail order.











SUMMARY
There is nothing more frustrating in modelling than a single volume (apart from Hunnicutt) which pretends to cover the entire history and variants of a subject as inherently complex as the Sherman. In this new book by the Polish Publisher ModelBooks, the M4a2 is covered in considerable depth. Using a mixture of color photos of (well) preserved examples, contemporary photographs, details from the original technical manuals and a series of well-presented scale drawings in both 1/72nd and 1/35th scale, the author has presented an impressive book for those who wish to give their M4a2 models that extra touch...
  DETAIL:80%
  QUALITY OF IMAGES/PLANS:90%
  SUBJECT MATTER:80%
Percentage Rating
90%
  Scale: Other
  Mfg. ID: 839202544X
  Suggested Retail: Around $12
  PUBLISHED: Aug 29, 2005
  NATIONALITY: United States
NETWORK-WIDE AVERAGE RATINGS
  THIS REVIEWER: 88.06%
  MAKER/PUBLISHER: 91.11%

About Jim Rae (jimbrae)
FROM: PROVINCIA DE LUGO, SPAIN / ESPAñA

Self-employed English teacher living in NW Spain. Been modelling off and on since the sixties. Came back into the hobby around ten years ago. First love is Soviet Armor with German subjects running a close second. Currently exploring ways of getting cloned to allow time for modelling, working and wr...

Copyright ©2017 text by Jim Rae [ JIMBRAE ]. All rights reserved.


Reader Reviews
Do you own this item and want to review it? You can add your review of the item here. Please read the reader review instructions before posting.

   

What's Your Opinion?


Photos
Click image to enlarge
  • shermanbook_002
  • shermanbook_004
  • shermanbook_001
  • sherbook1
  • sherbook2