login   |    register
Browse Sites

Scale Modeling Sponsors

See Your Ad Here!


Kamizukuri [ MORE REVIEWS ] [ WEB SITE ] [ NEW STORIES ]

In-Box Review


Sd.Kfz.7/1 Lattice Guard Set (1:35)
Sd.Kfz.7/1 Lattice Guard Set for Dragon CyberHobby

by: Bill Cross [ BILL_C ]


introduction

One of the real challenges for recreating the Sd.Kfz.7/1 and 7/2 in 1/35th scale is the complex slat “mesh” used on the fold-down ramps/sides of at least early war versions (and judging by photos and German Wochenschau newsreels other halftracks as well). There is some dispute about the composition of the side ramps, with a sampling of period photos seeming to show ordinary mesh, while the few surviving museum examples have what can only be described as a complicated lattice-work array that’s not unlike the modern Stryker’s slat armor (see photo at right from the excellent book in the "Wings & Wheels" series, Sd.Kfz.7 In Detail, reviewed by me here). The ramps presumably gave gun crews a secure footing when in the combat mode, and were lighter than metal sides. Not surprisingly, both Dragon and Trumpeter’s Sd.Kfz.7/1s and 7/2s use fairly conventional photo etch mesh to render the screens, with both versions technically incorrect.

Dragon in its later war Sd.Kfz.7/2 and Trumpeter in its later war, armored cab Sd.Kfz.7/1 both offer the modeler the choice of wooden sides (rendered in styrene) and mesh. Both choices are accurate, and DML even refers to the mesh option as “museum” mesh (see Jim Starkweather's review here for more). Whether the Germans gave up on this complicated system in favor of ordinary mesh screening (as they did when switching to wooden sides), or the photos are simply inconclusive remains a topic of discussion. But there can be no doubt Griffon Model has taken on the challenge of rendering the slat mesh sides as accurately as the original with its set of PE for the Sd.Kfz.7/1 (reviewed by me here).

The problem with the Griffon set is it’s extremely complicated to assemble: you have to separate steel components from their frets, bend the base frame to shape with the vertical slats in the "up" position, glue all the horizontal slats in-place, then assemble the various sections into a frame that must be glued-together literally piece-by-piece. For those who want the ultimate in detailing, the set is the answer. For those who are willing to accept a slightly lower level of authenticity for a HUGE improvement in convenience and ease-of-assembly, a Japanese AM supplier called Kamizukuri has released slatted mesh side panels that are made from laser-cut paper for both the Sd.Kfz.7/1 and 7/2 (the vehicles had slightly different rear panel dimensions).

the kit

The set comes in a clear-glassine envelope and includes:

A sheet of 3 laser-cut paper slatted mesh panels plus support brackets
1 fret of laser-cut paper for the pins and latches securing the panels
A sheet of illustrated instructions

the review

The set is almost ready-to-use straight out of the packaging with little more needed than a sharp hobby knife and some viscous white glue. In fact, CA glue doesn’t work very well on the paper’s slick surface (actually a thick, cardboard-like consistency). Assembly involves separating the panels from the main fret and gluing on the support brackets, then adding some fixtures that secured the sides when in the travel configuration.

The set is a bit strange for those of us weaned on styrene and now brass photo etch. You can actually smell the burning from the laser cutting process, and it’s important to be careful handling (and painting) the components. Too much torque and the various layers will separate. The manufacturer recommends putting down a thin base coat of some description to seal the paper’s absorbent surface, though you will not learn this information from the instructions: they’re almost entirely in Japanese. The simple assembly steps are rendered with drawings that are easy to understand, but I would have preferred something I could read, and I would urge Kamizukuri to provide an English-language update that could be downloaded from the Tasca website where the products are marketed and sold.

As you can see from the final photo in the selection at right comparing the two kit PE arrays, the Griffon Model set and this one, the mesh is not as to-scale as the Griffon PE. But blows away the PE supplied with both the Trumpeter and DML kits. Given the longer length of the Trumpeter side panels, this upgrade can’t be adapted to that kit, and Kamizukuri tells me they have no plans to release a version for the Trumpeter Sd.Kfz.7/1.

conclusion

While the laser-cut paper isn’t as accurate as the Griffon PE mesh slats, it’s so much easier to assemble, I can’t imagine anyone except the hardest-core rivet counter not wanting to at least consider this option. The good news keeps getting better, too, with a set available for Dragon’s Sd.Kfz.7/2. I want to thank Tasca for sending me this set for review.
SUMMARY
Highs: Simple to use, yet substantially upgrades the accuracy of the kit.
Lows: Not perfectly to-scale. Instructions only in Japanese.
Verdict: Definitely recommended.
OVERALL RATING
90%
  SCALE: 1:35
  ITEM ID: FP-2B
  PRICE: 1,140 Yen
  PUBLISHED: March 7th 2010
  NATIONALITY: Germany
NETWORK-WIDE AVERAGE RATINGS
  THIS REVIEWER: 87.93%
  KAMIZUKURI: 91.67%
 
3 of 3 people found this review helpful.
DISCUSS THIS REVIEW

Our Thanks to Tasca!
This item was provided by them for the purpose of having it reviewed on this KitMaker Network site. If you would like your kit, book, or product reviewed, please contact us.

View This Item   View Vendor Homepage

About Bill Cross (bill_c)
FROM: NEW JERSEY, UNITED STATES

Retrurning to the hobby after a VERY long hiatus (no, I was NOT in prison!).

Copyright ©2010 text by Bill Cross [ BILL_C ]. Images also by copyright holder unless otherwise noted. Opinions expressed are those of the author(s) and not necessarily those of Armorama. All rights reserved.


Reader Reviews
Do you own this item and want to review it? You can add your review of the item here. Please read the reader review instructions before posting.
YOU REVIEW THIS ITEM



Comments (17)SHOWING 10 COMMENTS     READ ALL / COMMENT

bill_c SAID
Bill Cross reviews Kamizukuri's Mesh Guard Set for DML''s Sd.Kfz.7/1. Link to Item If you have comments or questions please post them here. Thanks!

pzcreations SAID
Nice review Bill. Im still not sure which one I will use though. The Griffon set does look really complicated. One thing that might sway me though is how the scale thickness is on this set. From the photos its hard to tell. Do you have a better close-up of the thickness of this set? sorry, wanted to make your job even harder ==)

bill_c SAID
Thanks, Tim, try this: The Griffon Model set can't be touched for accuracy, but it does not assemble easily, and my first panel is warped a bit. Don't know if mounting it will ease that, and it will need some filling with Mr. Surfacer to clean it up.

pzcreations SAID
Thanks Bill...from the looks of it, I think I might just take the plunge and try the Griffon set. then I can feel your pain. |:(

bill_c SAID
Don't say I didn't warn you, LOL!!! :D :o) :D

Jerrers2000 SAID
Regarding the reference pictures - there's a picture in the Panzer Colours book of a crew changing out one of the barrels of an Sdkfz 7/1 in Normandy - and you can see in that pic it's a lattice array - rather than mesh. regards Jezza

bill_c SAID
Thanks, Jeremy, for pointing that out. I was watching some film of Barbarossa, and an Sd.Kfz.11 went by towing a small gun, and it was clearly a lattice-work array. But in some photos, the lack of contrast doesn't tell us clearly. Take this image from the Panzerkeil website:

metooshelah SAID
thanks for the review Bill! I'm very interested in those laser cut paper sets, and I hope to see more of them in the future as a simple replacement to PE parts (a laser cut paper set for the stryker! and so on) and i really like seeing more and more of these released.

gremlinz SAID
I bought a few of these for the 7/1s and 7/2s I have and I was really impressed with them. I don't know about the 7/1 as I only have the Dragon 7/1s and not the Trumpeter one but on the 7/2 the Kamizukiri one fits the Trumpeter one as well ( at least as far as dry fitting goes as I haven't put it together yet ). I'm also going to look at how hard it is to mod one for the Italeri 10/4.

bill_c SAID
Let me know how you do, Dean, as I have a 10/4 in the stash....


DISCUSS THIS REVIEW
   
ADVERTISEMENT

What's Your Opinion?
DISCUSS THIS REVIEW
YOU REVIEW THIS ITEM
REVIEW SOMETHING ELSE
3 of 3 people found this review helpful.


Photos
CLICK IMAGE TO ZOOM