login   |    register
E.T. Model [ MORE REVIEWS ] [ WEBSITE ] [ NEW STORIES ]

In-Box Review
135
17pdr Anti Tank Gun Mk I
  • move

by: Darren Baker [ CMOT ]

Introduction

It was not that long ago that Bronco released their 17pdr Anti Tank Gun Mk I, and it was very well received on its release. E.T. Model have quickly followed up the release of this kit with a photo etch upgrade set for the 17pdr Anti Tank Gun Mk I.

Contents

This product is supplied in a very heavy duty clear plastic bag with a card hanger, on which is printed all of the relevant information needed about what the product is for before making a purchase. Inside the bag there is a black card stiffener to help prevent flexing damage, and a sheet of green A4 sized piece of paper with the instructions printed on them. The product itself consists of two photo etch frets.

Review

The set itself primarily concentrates on replacing the gun shield and elements attached to the gun shield. The photo etch used to replace the gun shield and most of the elements attached to it is 0.30mm thick which is quite a heavy grade to work with, at 0.30mm when scaled up you get 10.5mm which is thicker I believe than the real item as I can lift the gun shield of a 25pdr on my own and I doubt I would manage a piece of metal sheet over these dimensions, that out of the way this should look more realistic scale wise.

The spacing pegs between the front and rear portions of the gun shield are separated by pegs which are not supplied with the product, you are instructed to use plastic pegs made from stock plastic which will likely be an exercise in frustration. I would have liked to see spacing pegs supplied with the product in order that the end user can be assured of getting an equal distance between the two shield elements. The bottom portion of the gun shield is designed to be moveable via hinges which are supplied already attached to the gun shield parts; however the instructions neglect to tell you what size pins to insert or for that matter neglects to inform you of the need for hinge pins at all. The 17pdr artillery guns I have seen have a notch cut into both shields which I suspect is used for an aspect of sighting the gun and it is worth mentioning that this is missing from both the base kit and after market option. I am not saying that this is wrong but it is something I have observed in the version I have seen.

The other sheet of photo etch that is supplied is 0.23mm thick and contains the loops that are placed on various parts of the gun, and tool retention straps. British military hardware frequently used leather belt straps to hold on tools and other items of equipment utilising metal loops attached to that piece of hardware, the parts on this fret would I suspect sell very well as a stand alone item for those interested in British military equipment. In this set they are used to secure the spade on the gun and is an excellent addition to the set.

Conclusion

This is a simple, well designed product with the smallest fret being the star of the show for me. The gun shield looks the part and I am sure is a better scale thickness than the kit supplied option if that aspect is important to you then this product may be for you.


17 Pdr Anti Tank Gun walk around by Jon R Greggs Live links


17 pdr Mk I/II walk around by Darren Baker Live links
SUMMARY
Highs: The attachment loops, belts, and buckles are the high point of this product for me and should be made available as a stand alone product.
Lows: Not including the pegs for separating the front and rear portions of the gun shield would seem to be a mistake to me.
Verdict: This is one of those sets that is difficult to have a verdict on as the gun shield will, I am sure, look better providing you can make the connecting pegs the right length. I will highly recommend the loops, belts, and buckles portion of the set.
  Scale: 1:35
  Mfg. ID: E35-039
  PUBLISHED: Aug 30, 2011
  NATIONALITY: United Kingdom
NETWORK-WIDE AVERAGE RATINGS
  THIS REVIEWER: 87.16%
  MAKER/PUBLISHER: 87.07%

Our Thanks to E.T. Model!
This item was provided by them for the purpose of having it reviewed on this KitMaker Network site. If you would like your kit, book, or product reviewed, please contact us.

View Vendor Homepage  |  More Reviews  

About Darren Baker (CMOT)
FROM: ENGLAND - SOUTH WEST, UNITED KINGDOM

I have been building model kits since the early 70ís starting with Airfix kits of mostly aircraft, then progressing to the point I am at now building predominantly armour kits from all countries and time periods. Living in the middle of Salisbury plain since the 70ís, I have had lots of opportunitie...

Copyright ©2019 text by Darren Baker [ CMOT ]. All rights reserved.



Comments

Hi Darren, Thanks for the review. I'm not sure why I'd want to buy this, especiallly as there is the absence of spacers between the shields, which as you say is an exercise in frustration waiting to happen. I think I'll stick with the kit shield that looks perfectly acceptable. Thanks agin. Al
AUG 30, 2011 - 10:26 PM
Alan, I was thinking much the same myself - "what does this bring that actually improves the kit?" Answer, not much. But thanks for the looksee Darren.
AUG 31, 2011 - 03:19 AM
All I can say in reply is that the small photo etched fret is excellent and recommend to E.T. Model to release that fret as a bigger offering to be used as a general set for British and Common Wealth AFVs. I suspect it would be very popular.
AUG 31, 2011 - 03:35 AM
   

What's Your Opinion?


Photos
Click image to enlarge
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move